Which is better MBA in consulting or finance?

Question

Aarushi S · Accepted Answer

Choosing between an MBA in consulting or finance depends on your career goals and the kind of work you enjoy. Consulting offers variety , you work across industries, solve strategic problems, and often travel. Finance is more numbers-driven, with roles in investment banking, asset management, or corporate finance.
If you enjoy structured analysis, markets, and high-pressure environments, finance may suit you better. Post-MBA salaries in finance roles like investment banking or private equity typically range from $175,000 to $200,000 (base + bonus). Consulting roles at top firms like BCG or Bain offer starting packages around $160,000 to $170,000.
Both fields offer fast-paced growth, global mobility, and strong exit options,  but the right pick depends on what you&rsquo;re better at: data and financial modeling lean toward finance; communication and problem-solving fit better with consulting.

Divakshi Arora · Answer

Both consulting and finance are top post-MBA paths, but they offer different experiences, salaries, and long-term career options. Here&rsquo;s a quick breakdown to help compare them side by side:

Consulting gives broader experience and smoother entry even without a finance background. Finance pays more but is harder to get into and less flexible. The better option depends on whether you want global variety or a high-stakes finance career.

Hema A · Answer

Both consulting and finance are strong MBA career paths, but they suit different goals. Consulting is better if you&rsquo;re looking for flexibility, global exposure, and cross-industry learning. Firms like McKinsey, BCG, and Bain recruit heavily from top schools and offer roles across regions. Average post-MBA salaries start at $165K&ndash;$175K base, with bonuses up to $50K. Visa sponsorship and global mobility are big plus points here.
Finance is a good option if the focus is purely on high compensation and working in investment banking, private equity, or asset management. Roles in firms like Goldman Sachs, Blackstone, and JPMorgan often start at $175K&ndash;$200K base, with high bonuses. But it&rsquo;s more competitive, requires a strong finance profile, and is concentrated in specific cities like New York or London.
So, if the goal is career growth with optionality across industries and countries, consulting makes more sense. If it&rsquo;s long-term wealth and a specialized finance track, finance is the way to go.

B.K Sharma · Answer

There&rsquo;s no one-size-fits-all answer &mdash; but here&rsquo;s how consulting and finance MBAs compare:

Consulting: Ideal for those who enjoy variety, strategic thinking, and working across industries. Top firms (McKinsey, BCG, Bain) offer packages around $165,000&ndash;$175,000 including signing bonuses.
Finance: Suits those who enjoy markets, analysis, and high-pressure roles. Investment banking and private equity salaries typically start between $175,000&ndash;$220,000 with bonus.
Work-life balance: Consulting often involves travel but slightly better hours. Finance (especially banking) is more intense, with longer workweeks.
Growth: Consulting can lead to roles in corporate strategy or operations. Finance offers clearer tracks to roles like investment manager, VP of finance, or CFO.
Location matters: Finance roles are heavily concentrated in NYC, London, and Hong Kong. Consulting firms recruit globally.
Recruiting process: Consulting is case-based, while finance recruiting is more technical and network-driven.

If undecided, choose an MBA program like Wharton, Booth, or INSEAD that gives strong access to both &mdash; so you can test each path during internships.